The Cost Breakdown: What Goes Into a Siding Estimate

If you’re a homeowner in Ohio thinking about replacing your siding, you’ve probably noticed estimates can vary quite a bit. One company might quote $15,000, another $25,000—and it leaves you wondering: what actually goes into that number?

At American Way Exteriors, we believe an estimate should make sense, not just look like a total at the bottom of a page. Let’s break down what drives siding costs—materials, labor, and everything in between—so you can understand where your investment goes and why it matters.

1. Materials: Where Most of the Cost Begins

Your siding material is the biggest factor in the estimate.

Below is an overview of common siding materials, what they include, and how much they typically cost per square foot installed:

Vinyl Siding ($6–$9 per sq. ft.)

Vinyl is the most budget-friendly siding option. It’s lightweight, easy to install, and available in many colors. While it resists rot and insects, it can warp or fade over time, especially in areas with strong sun exposure.

• Material cost: $2–$4 per sq. ft.
• Labor cost: $4–$5 per sq. ft.
• Pros: Affordable, low maintenance.
• Cons: Less durable in extreme weather, limited design depth.

Cedar or Wood Siding ($10–$16 per sq. ft.)

Wood siding brings natural warmth and charm, making it popular for homeowners who love the traditional look. However, Ohio’s humidity and temperature swings mean wood requires regular sealing or staining to prevent rot and insects.

• Material cost: $5–$8 per sq. ft.
• Labor cost: $5–$8 per sq. ft. (more due to careful fitting and cutting).
• Pros: Beautiful and timeless.
• Cons: High maintenance, prone to water damage without proper care.

James Hardie Fiber Cement Siding ($11–$14 per sq. ft.)

Fiber cement is the premium choice for long-term performance. It’s engineered to handle harsh Midwest weather—resistant to moisture, warping, pests, and fire. Installed properly by certified professionals like American Way Exteriors, it can last 30–50 years with minimal upkeep.

• Material cost: $6–$8 per sq. ft.
• Labor cost: $5–$6 per sq. ft. (requires special cutting tools and expertise).
• Pros: Extremely durable, stunning appearance, backed by a 30-year warranty.
• Cons: Slightly higher upfront cost, heavier material.

These prices typically include trim, flashing, and house wrap, but not always tear-off or underlying repairs, which we’ll cover next.

2. Labor: The Heart of the Estimate

Labor is often the second-largest cost factor—and it’s where quality really counts. Installing siding the right way is almost just as important as choosing the right material.

At American Way Exteriors, our crew members are trained in James Hardie’s best-practice installation system, which means:

• Every panel is properly sealed and flashed.
• Fasteners are corrosion-resistant and installed to manufacturer standards.
• Joints are aligned and caulked to protect against Ohio’s freeze-thaw cycles.

Labor typically ranges from $4–$7 per sq. ft., depending on:

• The complexity of your home’s architecture (e.g., multiple stories, gables, or intricate trim).
• Accessibility (tight spaces or steep grades require more setup).
• Removal and disposal of old siding.

A quality labor estimate also includes prep work—inspecting and repairing any rotted sheathing or framing beneath your old siding. Skipping this step can lead to bigger issues later, even if the new siding looks perfect at first glance.

3. Additional Materials & Finishing Touches

A complete siding project includes more than just panels. Here’s what else is typically included in your quote:

• Trim and Soffits: $2–$4 per linear foot. Adds definition and protection around windows, doors, and rooflines.
• House Wrap or Weather Barrier: $0.50–$1 per sq. ft. Keeps moisture out and improves energy efficiency.
• Caulking and Flashing: Small items that make a big difference in sealing gaps and preventing leaks.
• Paint or Finishing (if applicable): For some fiber cement or wood products, custom painting adds about $1–$2 per sq. ft.

4. Total Cost Range

For a typical 2,000-square-foot Ohio home, here’s what a siding replacement might cost on average:

• Vinyl: $12,000 – $18,000
• Cedar/Wood: $20,000 – $32,000
• James Hardie Fiber Cement: $22,000 – $28,000

Keep in mind, local conditions (like Cincinnati vs. Cleveland) and the specific design of your home can shift these numbers slightly.

5. Why Estimates Can Differ

Two contractors might give very different quotes for the same home. That’s usually due to differences in:

• Material quality and manufacturer partnerships.
• Labor expertise and warranty coverage.
• Whether old siding removal, sheathing repair, or trim work are included in the base price.

At American Way Exteriors, our quotes are detailed and transparent—you’ll see exactly what’s included before we start. We also provide 3D design previews so you can visualize your siding before installation even begins.

If you’re ready for a clear, honest estimate and professional guidance, contact American Way Exteriors today.